We are webs.ie, a small web and AI studio in Dublin. On 29 August 2026 we asked Google's AI the question a Dublin householder types when the immersion heater packs in: plumber dublin. Then we pulled the list of websites its answers actually quote.
Google's AI Overviews is the summary Google now prints above the ordinary blue links. The data below shows it answering Irish searches, and most people reading this have been shown one without thinking about it.
Of the ten sites its answers cite most often, six are job boards or salary sites. Indeed, Jooble, IrishJobs, Glassdoor, careersportal.ie, salaryexpert.com. Exactly one working plumbing business is on the list, in seventh place.
Read that as the owner of any small Irish business with a website that works fine. Google's AI is quoting the sites that answer "how do I become a plumber". Barely any of them answer "who do I hire".
We checked two other trades as well. There is a five-minute check at the end of this article that tells you where your own stands, and it costs nothing to run.
The figures are ours, pulled on 29 August 2026 from DataForSEO's index of AI answers, filtered to Google AI Overviews, Ireland, English: 112 mentions for that phrase.

Then we checked two more trades
Solicitors is sharper. For solicitor dublin, AI Overviews carried 424 mentions in Ireland, against a monthly AI search volume of 138,350 on DataForSEO's estimate.
Not one Dublin law firm is in the top twelve sources. The AI reaches for Citizens Information, the Law Society, Reddit, Wikipedia, Indeed, Facebook and the Courts Service first. The first actual firm, Roe Solicitors, comes in at thirteen, and across the whole top twenty only two cited sites are law firms.

Dentists is the fair counterweight. For dentist dublin, six of the top ten cited sites are real practices, 3Dental and Dental Care Ireland among them. That trade is doing something the other two are not. Four slots still go to Indeed, YouTube, Facebook and a dentistry jobs board.
Two honest limits. This is AI Overviews, not ChatGPT: we tried the same read for ChatGPT and could not get it, because that dataset is United States English only, and when we ran dentist dublin it resolved Dublin to Dublin, Virginia. And these are small numbers, 112 mentions for the plumber phrase, in an Irish index far smaller than the UK's. Small samples move around.
Update, 4 November 2026: the same pull, run again
We re-ran the three searches on 4 November 2026 with the same call as in August: DataForSEO's AI Optimization LLM Mentions endpoint, aggregated metrics, platform Google (AI Overviews), Ireland, English, word match on the phrase, top twenty source domains by mentions. The counting rule is also the same: the top ten as the API returns them, job boards and salary sites counted as such, a business counted only if its own site sells the service. The August figures above are unchanged. Cost: US$0.303 for the three calls (the cost field in DataForSEO's responses, 4 November 2026).
The index is cumulative, so every count grew. Compare who is on the list, not the raw numbers.
| Search | Mentions, 29 Aug | Mentions, 4 Nov | AI search volume, 29 Aug | AI search volume, 4 Nov |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| plumber dublin | 112 | 178 | 43,790 | 60,340 |
| solicitor dublin | 424 | 566 | 138,350 | 176,280 |
| dentist dublin | 134 | 195 | 34,560 | 47,930 |
What did not change: the pattern. Job and salary sites still take about half of the plumber list, no Dublin law firm sits clearly above the regulator, the State and Reddit, and dentists are still the trade where real practices get named most. What did change: the plumbing business dropped out of the top ten, and the dentist count slipped by one. We would not call either a trend. Two pulls three months apart from a rolling index, with ties at tenth place, show that the pattern held, not that it is moving. We keep the figures from both pulls.
Does any of this cost you money yet?
Partly. Here is the careful version.
Partly, and the verified evidence is narrow. Pew Research Center tracked 68,879 US Google searches in March 2025 and found people clicked a traditional result link in 8% of visits to pages with an AI summary, against 15% of visits to pages without one (Pew Research Center, July 2025). That is a US study. We have not found an Irish click-through study we can verify, so we quote none.
In plain terms, what changed is that a machine now stands between the question and your front door, deciding who gets named.
Why the machine skips you
Three reasons, and none of them are your fault.
It reads a different page than you see. If your prices, your service list or your opening hours only appear after the page finishes loading itself inside someone's browser, several of these readers never see them at all.The precise version, because this is the part people argue about:
A log study by Vercel and MERJ, published on 17 December 2024, found that GPTBot, ClaudeBot and PerplexityBot fetch pages but do not run JavaScript, so text that only appears after scripts run can be missed. The same study found that Applebot and Google's Gemini, which uses Googlebot's infrastructure, do render JavaScript (Vercel, "The rise of the AI crawler"). That study is nearly a year old and crawler behaviour changes, so test your own page with check two below. Neither OpenAI's nor Anthropic's crawler documentation says how its bots render a page.

We found the worst example of it on our own blog, while writing this. Every article on webs.ie, this one included, had its words fetched by a script after the page arrived, so GPTBot, ClaudeBot and PerplexityBot read the whole journal as three words. We moved the rendering to the server the same afternoon and re-checked every article using the crawlers’ own user agent. You can check us: Ctrl and U on this page, then search for this sentence.
Job boards publish their facts in a form machines can read. Indeed does not out-write a plumber. It labels every listing with the trade, the county, the pay and the date as structured data, hidden tags telling a machine what each thing on the page is. The trade sites we audit usually leave the same facts as ordinary sentences in a paragraph, with nothing to tell a machine which part is the price and which is the county. Your own security may be the one saying no. Cloudflare announced on 1 July 2026 that from 15 September 2026, new domains onboarding to Cloudflare get new defaults: bots it classes as Training or Agent are blocked on pages that display ads, Search stays allowed, and customers can opt out before that date (Cloudflare changelog). The post describes new domains only, so do not assume it applies to your site. If your site is behind Cloudflare, open its AI crawler settings and see what is set.We caught one of these on ourselves the same morning. Our AI product's site, sitebrain.app, was turning AI crawlers away with a 403. It was fixed that day.
Some of these visitors have no name at all
The advice everywhere is "block the AI bots", or "allow the AI bots". Both are out of date, because a growing number of them arrive without a name.
When we read Cloudflare's verified-bot directory on 29 August 2026, most entries filed under Agent carried no user-agent string. They sign each request with a cryptographic key your site can check instead. We have not re-read the directory since, so treat the detail as a dated observation. Other agents run on a person's own laptop and take the identity of whatever tool they use, which is why a name list alone cannot tell you who is calling.
Two practical consequences. Google says there are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews, and lists nosnippet, data-nosnippet, max-snippet and noindex as the controls (Google Search Central, AI features). Google-Extended is the opt-out for AI training and for grounding in some of Google's other systems, so blocking it is not how you leave AI Overviews. And a robots.txt block does not cover every fetcher: OpenAI says that for ChatGPT-User, which acts when a person asks, "robots.txt rules may not apply" (OpenAI), while Anthropic says its bots honour robots.txt.
Check your own site in five minutes
Nothing to install, and you do not need us for it.

- Ask the machine your customer's question. Open ChatGPT or Google's AI Mode and type what a good customer would type. "Emergency dentist Dublin 8." "Employment solicitor Dublin." Are you named? Who is? A directory and two competitors is your result.
- Read your own page the way a machine does. Open your website and press Ctrl and U together (Cmd, Option and U on a Mac). A window of raw code appears. Press Ctrl and F and paste in a sentence from the middle of your page. No match means that sentence never reached the readers that skip JavaScript.
- Check the doorman. Type your own address followed by /robots.txt, so yoursite.ie/robots.txt, into the browser bar. Look for Disallow lines underneath GPTBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot or OAI-SearchBot. That is your website turning those readers away, usually because a plugin or a host put it there years ago.
If all three come back clean you are in better shape than most sites we audit.
What we do about it
We call it Agent Readiness and it is unglamorous work. Your words move into the HTML your server sends instead of being assembled afterwards. Your services, area, hours and prices get labelled as structured data. Which bots get in becomes a decision instead of an accident. Then we re-test and show you the before and after.
You already know whether step two or step three made you wince. Send us the address and we will do the rest: what Google and the AI assistants can see on your site, what is turning them away, and whether they name you for the questions your customers actually ask. In plain English, with the fixes ordered by what they are likely to do to your enquiries. The first check is free, and if there is nothing worth fixing we will say so.
Agent Readiness, done for you